Find your person on the list and see what they want.
The gift should be AT LEAST $20.
There are some links to what people want so I put them below the items listed.

TEO
Taking Back Sunday's DVD titled "Louder Now: Part One": http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000JMKKGS/ref=pd_kar_gw_2/103-2155940-8799826
guitar stand:
http://www.zzounds.com/item--MUPXCG4
PC headset:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16826275009

JENNIFER
Grey’s Anatomy Season 1 DVD
Victoria’s Secret gift card

DARYL
Bob Marley shirt
Stress squeeze ball

BYRON
Shirts, belts, beanies, or gift cards from American Eagle, Hollister, or Abercrombie

GIAN
the New Sean Lennon (not john) cd titled "friendly fire'
Oral-B electric toothbrush
A scanner darkly dvd

KEVIN
Barnes and Noble gift card
Starbucks gift card
Target gift card

KRISTOPHER
Yo-yo (any kind that sleeps)
Best Buy gift card
Fry’s gift card
Any gift cards from a cool electronics store
ipod nano AC adapter...only 19.95

ERIN
American Eagle gift card
L&L gift card
Jamba Juice gift card
Starbucks gift card
Best Buy gift card
Anything food related

KRISTINA
Glove mittens (cream colored)
http://www.ae.com/web/browse/product.jsp?rcid=womens&scid=cat90054&navroot=womens&productId=0426_6007
ear muffs (cream colored)
Visa gift card
A skinny black leather belt

JENELYN
Barnes and Noble gift card
Mac Apple store gift card
Target gift card

KHAING
Starbucks gift card
Forever 21 gift card
Fashion Q gift card